To the Editor:
We write concerning the recently published article by Klougart et al, (Klougart N; Leboeuf-Yde C, Rasmussen LR. Safety in chiropractic practice. Part II: Treatment to the upper neck and the rate of cerebrovascular incidents. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1996; 19:563-9). The authors should be commended for their exhaustive efforts in evaluating the occurrence of cerebrovascular incidents in chiropractic practice, a topic of great interest and importance to the profession (1, 2). Based on earlier conclusions by these authors (1); their present study (2) and the findings of other authors (3-5), cervical spine .rotational maneuvers have been found to be clearly more associated with cerebrovascular accidents (CVAs) and cerebrovascular incidents (CVIs), after spinal manipulation than other techniques. Perhaps because of this fact, and the knowledge of the effects of rotation upon vertebral artery blood flow (6), the authors attempted to classify technique procedures as “rotation’. or “nonrotation” in their retrospective analysis to estimate the occurrence of CVI s after chiropractic treatment to the cervical spine.
Although the authors had good intentions in their survey to attempt to identify what techniques might be associated with CVIs, inherent problems exist in administering such a. survey to chiropractors. The shortcomings may include (a) the failure to report the use of several different techniques in a given treatment session (7, 8); (b) the reporting of a practitioner that they are using a particular system (i.e., Gonstead), when in actuality they are not using the appropriate protocols, screening procedures, case management, set-ups, lines of drive, segmental contact points and vectors or magnitude of force as taught and recommended by such a system and (c) a wide variation of competency among practitioners (9). These issues complicate the meaningfulness of any evaluation of a particular chiropractic technique.
Although the authors acknowledged that “the unwanted side effects” of the Gonstead technique may have been due to a modification of the technique by the chiropractor, and that it may “include a stronger element of rotation/extension than is generally thought,” several questions still arise. Pertaining to the six cases reportedly classified as “Gonstead,” were any of the treating practitioners trained in the Gonstead technique, and how many hours of study were dedicated to such training? Were any of the chiropractors certified in the Gonstead technique? Did the practitioners use the protocols and screening procedures suggested by the Gonstead system (10)? Did the reported “Gonstead” practitioners use elements of rotation in the set-up, or thrust procedure and to what degree (e.g.,-in case 10 it was reported that no rotation was used, but in the other 5 cases it was not mentioned whether rotation was used or not).
Moreover, assuming that “rotation” refers to rotation of the cervical spine, or + or – 0 Y designation suggested by White and Panjabi (11), for any valid conclusions to be made in a study of technique comparison, differentiation must be made between techniques that provide a thrust at the end range of the motion and those that only exhibit limited + or – 0 Y rotation in the set-up and thrust. Classification of a particular technique into one of three categories (rotational, low rotational or nonrotational) instead of two (rotational or nonrotational) would be more appropriate for significance. The authors classified Gonstead as “mainly nonrotation,” yet elements of + or – 0 Y are routinely included in both the set-up and thrust procedures for the cervical spine in the Gonstead technique (10). Gonstead, therefore, should have been classified under rotational or “low rotational,” which would have significantly affected the extrapolated estimates for rotation and nonrotation treatments regarding risk estimates for CVIs among technique procedures.
To expound further, another case in question, specifically case 6, was considered a case of “definite nonrotation,” which involved a patient who developed CVI-related symptoms after receiving “Traction” and “Activator” combined in the treatment. The authors used this data to formulate their conclusion, “although there seems to be a link between upper cervical rotation manipulative techniques and cerebrovascular incidents, treatment to the lower neck and the use of other techniques are implicated. as well.”
Because both traction and Activator were used in the treatment of the patient in case 6, and the methodology of neither treatment was neither explained nor discussed, it is impossible to draw a conclusion specific to the use of Activator or a “nonrotation” technique in this case, which deserves mention. The authors failed to provide discussion of this issue, as they did pertaining to “Gonstead technique” in the preceding paragraph regarding the modification of the technique by the individual chiropractor. We want to make it clear that practitioners trained in use of the Activator Adjusting Instrument (AAI) and Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique (AMCT) are not taught to incorporate traction into treatment regimens and, furthermore, that cervical spinal adjustments/manipulations are performed in the prone neutral position (12-14). Because there are several types of traction in use in chiropractic practice, some of which contain postures away from neutral including flexion and extension (15), the authors understandably referenced how the vertebral artery can be affected through traction (16). They further noted that “toggle” and “Activator” techniques seem not to be under suspicion in CVIs after spinal manipulation.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1997 Oct;20(8):567-8. [PMID:9345689]
Author information: Colloca CJ, Fuhr AW. Activator Methods International Ltd., Phoenix, AZ.
More in this category: A Prospective, Randomized, Double Blind, Placebo Controlled Clinical Trial Assessing the Effects of Applying a Force to C5 by a Mechanically Assisted Instrument (MAI) on Referred Pain to the Shoulder » Resolution of Lower Limb Sensory Polyneuropathy In A 63-Year-Old Male Receiving Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique For The Correction Of Vertebral Subluxation » Characteristics of Paraspinal Muscle Spindle Response to Mechanically Assisted Spinal Manipulation: A Preliminary Report » Spinal Tissue Loading Created by Different Methods of Spinal Manipulative Therapy Application. » Glucose Metabolic Changes in the Brain and Muscles of Patients with Nonspecific Neck Pain Treated by Spinal Manipulation Therapy: A [18F]FDG PET Study » Manual and Instrument Applied Cervical Manipulation for Mechanical Neck Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial. » Manual and Instrument Applied Cervical Manipulation for Mechanical Neck Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial. » Clinical Trials » Attenuation Effect of Spinal Manipulation on Neuropathic and Postoperative Pain Through Activating Endogenous Anti-Inflammatory Cytokine Interleukin 10 in Rat Spinal Cord » Resolution of Cervicalgia, Paraesthesia and Chronic Adhesive Capsulitis in a 67-Year-Old Male: A Case Study » A Randomized Controlled Trial to Measure the Effects of Specific Thoracic Chiropractic Adjustments on Blood Pressure and Pulse Rate » Neural Response During a Mechanically Assisted Spinal Manipulation in an Animal Model: A Pilot Study » Comparison of spinal manipulation methods and usual medical care for acute and subacute low back pain: a randomized clinical trial. » In Vitro Biomechanical Evaluation of Single Impulse and Repetitive Mechanical Shockwave Devices Utilized for Spinal Manipulative Therapy » Safety & Effectiveness: The Foundations of Success » The Chiropractic Report – May 2014 » Neural responses to the mechanical parameters of a high-velocity, low-amplitude spinal manipulation: effect of preload parameters. » A pilot study of a chiropractic intervention for management of chronic myofascial temporomandibular disorder. » Review of methods used by chiropractors to determine the site for applying manipulation. » The Activator Story: Development of a New Concept in Chiropractic. » Effects of thrust amplitude and duration of high velocity low amplitude spinal manipulation on lumbar muscle spindle responses to vertebral position and movement. » Comparison of paraspinal cutaneous temperature measurements between subjects with and without chronic low back pain. » Chiropractic management of a veteran with lower back pain associated with diffuse idiopathic skeletal hypertrophy and degenerative disk disease » Changes in pressure pain thresholds and Basal electromyographic activity after instrument-assisted spinal manipulative therapy in asymptomatic participants: a randomized, controlled trial. » Clinical effectiveness of the Activator adjusting instrument in the management of musculoskeletal disorders: a systematic review of the literature. » Chiropractic spinal manipulative therapy for a geriatric patient with low back pain and comorbidities of cancer, compression fractures, and osteoporosis » Resolution of Breech Presentation Confirmed by Ultrasound Following Webster’s Technique » Evaluation of Mechanical Allodynia in an Animal Immobilization Model using the Von Frey Method » Cerebral Metabolic Changes in Men After Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation for Neck Pain » Interexaminer Reliability of Supine Leg Checks for Discriminating Leg-Length Inequality » Diagnostic Accuracy of the Clinical Examination in Identifying the Level of Herniation in Patients with Sciatica » Measuring the Effects of Specific Cervical Chiropractic Adjustments on Blood Pressure and Pulse Rate: A Randomized Controlled Trial » Intermittent low back pain referred from a uterine adenomyosis: a case report » Fall Risk Profile and Quality-of-Life Status of Older Chiropractic Patients » Immediate Effects of the Audible Pop from a Thoracic Spine Thrust Manipulation on the Autonomic Nervous System and Pain: A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Clinical Trial » Inflammatory response following a short-term course of chiropractic treatment in subjects with and without chronic low back pain. » Relative effectiveness and adverse effects of cervical manipulation, mobilisation and the activator instrument in patients with sub-acute non-specific neck pain: results from a stopped randomised trial. » Chiropractic management of a 5-year-old boy with urinary and bowel incontinence » Chiropractic care of a 6 year old girl with neck pain; headaches; hand, leg and foot pain; and other nonmusculoskeletal symptoms » The safety and effectiveness of pediatric chiropractic: a survey of chiropractors and parents in a practice-based research network » Heart Rate Variability Modulation After Manipulation in Pain-Free Patients vs Patients in Pain » Interexaminer Reliability of a Leg Length Analysis Procedure Among Novice and Experienced Practitioners » Technique Systems used by post-1980 graduates of the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College practicing in five Canadian provinces: a preliminary survey » Relative Immediate Effect of Ischaemic Compression and Activator Trigger Point Therapy on Active Upper Trapezius Trigger Points: A Randomized Trial » Treatment of Paroxysmal Supraventricular Tachycardia using Instrument-Assisted Manipulation of the Fourth Rib: A 6 Year Study » Effects of a Manually Assisted Mechanical Force on Cutaneous Temperature » Interexaminer Reliability of the Prone Leg Length Analysis Procedure » Variability of Force Magnitude and Force Duration in Manual and Instrument-Based Manipulation Techniques » Three-Dimensional Vertebral Motions Produced by Mechanical Force Spinal Manipulation » Activator as a theraputic instrument: Survey of usage and opinions amongst members of the British Chiropractic Association » A Hypothesis of Chronic Back Pain: Ligament Subfailure Injuries Lead to Muscle Control Dysfunction » Spinal Manipulation Reduces Pain and Hyperalgesia after Lumbar Intervertebral Foramen Inflammation in the Rat » Chiropractic Treatment of Temporomandibular Disorders Using the Activator Adjusting Instrument and Protocol » Spinal Manipulation Alters Electromyographic Activity of Paraspinal Muscles: A Descriptive Study » A Randomized Clinical Trial of the Relative Effectiveness of Manual Versus Mechanical Force Chiropractic Adjustments in the Management of Sacroiliac Joint Syndrome » Status of Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique, Theory and Practice » A review of the literature pertaining to the efficacy, safety, educational requirements, uses and usage of mechanical adjusting devices. Part 2 of 2 » Active Trunk Extensor Contributions to Dynamic Posteroanterior Lumbar Spinal Stiffness » A review of the literature pertaining to the efficacy, safety, educational requirements, uses and usage of mechanical adjusting devices. Part 1 of 2 » Neuromechanical Characterization of in Vivo Lumbar Spinal Manipulation. Part II. Neurophysiological Response » Neuromechanical Characterization of In Vivo Lumbar Spinal Manipulation. Part I. Vertebral Motion » Chiropractic Management of Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome: A Report of Two Cases » Chiropractic Treatment of Temporomandibular Disorders Using the Activator Adjusting Instrument: A Prospective Case Series » Lateral Cervical Curve Changes in Patients Receiving Chiropractic Care After A Motor Vehicle Collision: A Retrospective Case Series » Comparison of Dynamic Posteroanterior Spinal Stiffness to Plain Film Radiographic Images of Lumbar Disk Height » Chiropractic Name techniques in Canada: a continued look at demographic trends and their impact on issues of jurisprudence » A Review of Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique » A Novel Method For Assessing Elbow Pain Resulting From Epicondylitis » Force-deformation response of the lumbar spine: a sagittal plane model of posteroanterior manipulation and mobilization » Chiropractic Treatment of Postsurgical Neck Syndrome With Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted Short-Lever Spinal Adjustments » The Effective Forces Transmitted by High-Speed, Low-Amplitude Thoracic Manipulation » Stiffness and Neuromuscular Reflex Response of the Human Spine to Posteroanterior Manipulative Thrusts In Patients With Low Back Pain » Rating Specific Chiropractic Technique Procedures for Common Low Back Conditions » The diagnostic performance of vertebral displacement measurements derived from ultrasonic indentation in an in vivo model of degenerative disc disease » Fibromyalgia & Chronic Myofascial Pain Syndrome – A Survival Manual » Chiropractic “Name Techniques”: A Review of the Literature » A Pilot Randomized Clinical Trial on the Relative Effect of Instrumental Versus Manual Thrust Manipulation in the Treatment of Cervical Spine Dysfunction. » In Vivo Transient Vibration Assessment of the Normal Human Thoracolumbar Spine » Muscular and Soft-Tissue Contributions of Dynamic Posteroanterior Spinal Stiffness » Lumbar Erector Spinae Reflex Responses to Mechanical Force, Manually- Assisted Thoracolumbar and Sacroiliac Joint Manipulation in Patients with Low Back Pain » Correlation of L5 Dynamic Posteroanterior Spinal Stiffness to Plain Film Radiographic Images of Lumbosacral Disc Height » Neurophysiological Response to Intraoperative Lumbosacral Spinal Manipulation » Name techniques in Canada: current trends in utilization rates and recommendations for their inclusion at the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College » The mechanics of spinal manipulation » Dynamic Response of the Human Lumbar Spine: A 5 DOF Lumped Parameter Time and Frequency Domain Model » Evaluating Teaching Effectiveness of the Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique Leg Check Based on Interexaminer Reliability » Electromyographic Responses To Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted Spinal Manipulative Therapy » Chiropractic Care for Patients Aged 55 Years and Older: Report from a Practice-Based Research Program » Mechanical Force Spinal Manipulation Increases Trunk Muscle Strength Assessed By Electromyography: A Comparative Controlled Clinical Trial » Reflex Responses Associated with Activator Treatment » Theory of small vertebral motions: an analytical model compared to data » Activator hand-held manual device included as part of the Medicare Carriers Manual Part 3 Chapter II Coverage of Chiropractic Services. » Interexaminer Reliability of Activator Method’s Relative Leg-Length Evaluation in the Prone Extended Position » Chiropractic Treatment of Coccygodynia via External Instrumental Adjusting Procedures utilizing Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique. » Muscular and Mechanical Behavior of the Lumbar Spine in Response to Dynamic Posteroanterior Forces » Validation of the Force and Frequency Characteristics of the Activator Adjusting Instrument: Effectiveness as a Mechanical Impedance Measurement Tool » Grand Rounds Discussion: Patient with acute low back pain » Treatment of Cervical Disc Protrusions Via Instrumental Chiropractic Adjustment. » Treatment of Symptomatic Lumbar Disc Herniation Utilizing Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique » Measurement of Soft Tissue Strain in Response to Consecutively Increased Compressive and Distractive Loads on a Friction-Based Test Bed » Movements of Vertebrae During Manipulative Thrusts to Unembalmed Human Cadavers » Safety in chiropractic practice. Part II: Treatment to the upper neck and the rate of cerebrovascular incidents. » The effects of spinal manipulation on the intensity of emotional arousal in phobic subjects exposed to a threat stimulus: a randomized, controlled, double-blind clinical trial. » Technique Overview: Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique » Engineering ─ In Vivo Transient Vibration Analysis of the Normal Human Spine » Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique » Comparison of Two Chiropractic Techniques on Pain and Lateral Flexion in Neck Pain Patients: a Pilot Study » Manipulation and mobilization of the cervical spine. A systematic review of the literature. » Three-Dimensional Head Kinematics and Cervical Range of Motion in the Diagnosis of Patients with Neck Trauma. » Oscillations of the Vertebrae in Spinal Manipulative Therapy » On Sounds and Reflexes of Cavitation » Back to Basics…Technology Assessment of the Chiropractic Subluxation » A Biomechanical Model of the Lumbar Spine During Upright Isometric, Flexion, Extension, and Lateral Bending » The Immediate Effect of Activator vs. Meric Adjustment on Acute Low Back Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial » Posterior Calcaneal Subluxation: An Important Consideration in Chiropractic Treatment of Plantar Fasciitis (Heel Spur Syndrome) » Instrumental Chiropractic Treatment of Frozen Shoulder Associated With Mixed Metastatic Carcinoma » Chiropractic Treatment of Frozen Shoulder Syndrome (Adhesive Capsulitis) Using Mechanical Force Manually Assisted Short Lever Adjusting Procedures. » Description and Analysis of Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique » Leg Length Inequality and the Side of Low Back Pain – A Pilot Study » Reflex Responses Associated with Manipulative Treatments on the Thoracic Spine: A Pilot Study » The Audible Release Associated with Joint Manipulation » Optoelectric Measurement of Changes in Leg Length Inequality Resulting from Isolation Tests » Conservative Treatment of Torn Medial Meniscus via Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted Short Lever Chiropractic Adjusting Procedures. » Measurement and Analysis of the In Vivo Posteroanterior Impulse Response of the Human Thoracolumbar Spine: A Feasibility Study » Dependence of the Delivered Force on the Force Setting on the Activator Adjusting Instrument » Instantaneous Helical Axis Estimation From 3-D Video Data in Neck Kinematics for Whiplash Diagnostics. » Optoelectric Measurement of Leg Length Inequalities Before, During, and After Isolation Tests. » The Activator Story: Development of a New Concept in Chiropractic » Biomechanical Characterization (fingerprinting) of Five Novel Methods of Cervical Spine Manipulation » Relationship between Preload and Peak Forces during Spinal Manipulative Treatments » Three-Dimensional Head Axis of Rotation During Tracking Movements: A Tool for Assessing Neck Neuromechanical Function » Optoelectric Measurement of Leg Length Changes During Isolation Tests » Responsiveness of leg alignment changes associated with articular pressure testing to spinal manipulation: the use of a randomized clinical trial design to evaluate a diagnostic test with a dichotomous outcome. » Reactivity of Leg Alignment to Articular Pressure Testing: Evaluation of a Diagnostic Test using a Randomized Crossover Clinical Trial Approach » Measurement and Analysis of Interspinous Kinematics » Evaluating Mechanical Force Manually Assisted Short Lever adjusting using an Anthropomorphic model » Treatment and biomechanical assessment of patients with chronic sacroiliac joint syndrome. » Treatment of Bell’s Palsy by Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted Chiropractic Adjusting and High-voltage Electrotherapy » Treatment of Bell’s Palsy by Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted Chiropractic Adjusting and High-voltage Electrotherapy » Three-dimensional Head Kinematics and Clinical Outcome of Patients with Neck Injury Treated with Spinal Manipulative Therapy: a Pilot Study » Vertebral Subluxation and Otitis Media: A Case Study » Motion Analysis as a Means to Objectify Changes in Apparent (Prone) Leg Length Inequality » Treatment of Chronic Sciatica by Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted, Short Lever Adjusting and a Video Assisted Stretching Program: A Quantitative Case Study » Non-Specific Short and Long Lever Chiropractic Adjusting: Principles and Practice » Mechanical Force, Manually Assisted, Short Lever Chiropractic Adjustment » Chiropractic Treatment Of Chronic Mechanical Low Back Pain In A Geriatric Population: A Practitioner-Scientist Protocol » Cervical spine: manipulative skill and performance considerations » The current status of Activator Methods Chiropractic Technique, theory, and training » Interexaminer Reliability of Eight Evaluative Dimensions of Lumbar Segmental Abnormality » Spinal learning: central modulation of pain processing and long-term alteration of interneuronal excitability as a result of nociceptive peripheral input. » Low Force Chiropractic Care of Two Patients with Sciatic Neuropathy and Lumbar Disc Herniation » Precise measurement of functional leg length inequality and changes due to cervical spine rotation in pain-free students. » Interexaminer Reliability of an Isolation Test for the Identification of Upper Cervical Subluxation » Interexaminer Reliability of Relative Leg Length Evaluations in the Prone Extended Position » Skin Accelerometer Displacement and Relative Bone Movement of Adjacent Vertebrae in Response to Chiropractic Percussion Thrusts » Effects of Chiropractic Treatment on Blood Pressure and Anxiety: A Randomized Controlled Trial » Reliability of the Derifield-Thompson test for leg length inequality, and use of the test to demonstrate cervical adjusting efficacy. » Effects of altered afferent articular input on sensation, proprioception, muscle tone and sympathetic reflex responses. » A model for the evaluation of chiropractic methods. » Accuracy of Piezoelectric Accelerometers Measuring Displacement of a Spinal Adjusting Instrument » The Force of the Activator® Adjusting Instrument » Inter- and intra-examiner reliability of leg-length differential measurement: a preliminary study. » Activator Adjusting For Acute Torticollis »